Insurance is one of the most critical tools in a real estate investor’s arsenal. From safeguarding properties against unforeseen disasters to ensuring financial stability during unexpected claims, a solid insurance strategy can make or break your portfolio. Yet, many investors underestimate the importance of understanding their policies, exposing them to unnecessary risks.
In a recent webinar hosted by PURE Property Management, Jock McNeill and Matt Nicholas tackled this vital topic, sharing expert insights and actionable advice. Matt, the First Vice President at Alliant Insurance Services, has over two decades of experience crafting insurance strategies for real estate and hospitality clients. Together, they explored how investors can effectively manage risks, navigate complex policies, and protect their investments.
Here’s a detailed summary of their insights, enhanced with definitions and actionable advice to help you navigate the complexities of insurance for rental properties.
Why Insurance Is a Cornerstone for Real Estate Investors
Insurance is more than a necessary expense—it’s a safeguard for your portfolio. Jock McNeil shared a personal experience that underscored the importance of having comprehensive and well-understood coverage. During a catastrophic wildfire in California, 28 of his client’s rental properties were destroyed in just eight hours. He noted how many investors lacked a clear understanding of their policies and were caught off guard by the gaps in their coverage.
This highlights a critical point: regular reviews of your insurance policies ensure they remain aligned with your current needs, helping you avoid surprises when disaster strikes.
The Core Insurance Policies Every Investor Needs
Insurance forms the backbone of any risk management strategy for property owners. Matt Nicholas outlined several essential policies that every real estate investor should consider:
- Property Insurance: Provides critical coverage for structures, contents, and loss of rental income caused by covered events like fire or storm damage. “Property insurance covers exactly what it sounds like: the building, the structures, the contents, the loss of rental income in the event that there’s one of those covered perils triggered,” Matt explained.
- Liability Insurance: Protects against claims for injuries sustained on your property. Matt emphasized, “Most investors should carry a $1 million umbrella, even if you have only one property.”
- Flood and Earthquake Insurance: Particularly important in high-risk zones, these policies often require standalone coverage.
- Matt explained that flood and earthquake insurance policies are critical in areas like California or the Pacific Northwest, where natural disasters are more frequent since these risks are typically not included in standard property insurance.
- Umbrella Insurance: Serves as an extra layer of protection, filling gaps in your liability coverage. Matt highlighted that umbrella policies are a cost-effective way to shield your assets, particularly as your portfolio grows.
Common Claims and Potential Gaps in Coverage
Claims can range from resident-related incidents to major property damage. Unattended cooking fires, for example, are among the most common resident-related claims. Matt suggested that simple preventative measures, such as fire suppression systems, can make a significant difference:
“Fire suppression systems are a couple of hundred dollars per stove. It can certainly prevent a major loss.”
However, insurance policies often contain exclusions or sublimits that investors should be aware of. A sublimit is a smaller coverage limit within a broader policy. For instance, while your policy might have a $1 million limit overall, it could have a $10,000 sublimit for mold damage. Mold and mildew are common exclusions unless additional coverage is purchased. Matt advised discussing such risks with your broker to ensure you’re fully protected.
How to Stay Ahead
To maximize the effectiveness of your insurance policies and manage costs, the experts shared these best practices:
- Review Policies Annually: Insurance carriers often change terms or exclusions year to year. Matt emphasized the importance of these reviews, explaining that many policyholders don’t realize their coverage has been reduced until it’s too late.
- Document Your Property: Keeping updated photos and records of your property, including renovations or upgrades, can streamline the claims process. As Matt explained, “It’s recommended to have somewhat updated photos of your structures and contents on file. That can only help the claims process.”
- Leverage Technology: Smart home devices such as water flow monitors, fire alarms, or CO2 detectors can prevent incidents and reduce insurance costs. For instance, Moen’s Flo Water Monitor attaches to your water main, alerts you to abnormal water usage, and allows you to shut off water remotely. These devices are becoming more recognized by insurance companies, and many offer discounts for using them.
- Work with a Property Manager: PURE’s services provide added value by reducing risks through expert resident screening and rapid emergency response. Matt noted that many insurance companies recognize the reduced risks associated with professional property management, which can lead to lower premiums.
- Understand Blanket Policies: Some property managers, like PURE, offer access to blanket insurance policies. These leverage the scale of the property manager’s portfolio to negotiate better terms and rates for individual investors. Matt explained that while not every blanket policy will suit every investor, they’re worth considering for their potential cost-saving benefits.
The Real Cost of Being Unprepared
Failing to keep your policy up to date can leave you underinsured, especially in times of widespread disasters. Jock recalled how rebuilding costs often outpaced insurance coverage during the California wildfire:
“Knowing you can’t rebuild your house for $150 a square foot is crucial. Your insurance policy needs to reflect today’s costs, especially in times of widespread disasters.”
This emphasizes the need to ensure your policy accurately reflects the current market cost for rebuilding, including labor and materials.
Additional Considerations
Investors should also pay attention to specific exclusions such as dog breed restrictions, wear and tear, or trampoline-related liabilities. These exclusions may vary by carrier and could significantly impac financial exposure.
Finally, when selecting an insurance provider, Matt advised looking for carriers with strong financial ratings, as assessed by agencies like AM Best.
- “An A9 or better rating indicates strong claims payout ability and financial stability,” he said, adding that investors should also compare the specific terms of the policies offered to ensure they meet their needs.
In Conclusion
Insurance is a powerful tool for protecting and growing your investments, but it requires careful attention to detail. From understanding policy exclusions to leveraging technology and professional property management, every decision adds a layer of security to your portfolio.
PURE Property Management is dedicated to helping investors navigate these challenges. With access to resources, expert advisors, and exclusive insurance programs, we aim to make real estate investment as secure and rewarding as possible.
Upcoming Webinar: Don’t miss our 2025 Rental Market Forecast. Register at blog.rentpure.com to secure your spot and gain insights into the trends shaping the industry.
