Renovating your rental property is a proven strategy to drive substantial returns. Upgrades can directly increase rental income, while boosting property value even further, especially when modernizing key areas like kitchens and bathrooms.
High-quality residents are more likely to seek out—and stay in—properties that offer updated amenities and well-maintained spaces, reducing vacancy rates and ensuring consistent rental income. In competitive rental markets, properties with contemporary features consistently outperform those without, making renovations a critical investment for long-term profitability.
Here is a great guide if you want a more comprehensive guide to increasing your rental income.
In this article, we will cover:
- the benefits of renovating your rental property,
- how to manage your renovation budget effectively,
- which renovations offer the highest return on investment,
- projects you can handle yourself,
- and crucial pitfalls to avoid.
You’ll have a detailed roadmap for maximizing your property’s potential by the end.
The Benefits of Renovating Your Rental Property
Renovating a rental property is not just about aesthetics—it’s an investment that offers tangible, measurable benefits that directly impact your bottom line. Here’s a breakdown of the most significant advantages:
Increased Rental Income
Renovating your rental property allows you to command higher rent, often by 10-20% or more, depending on the upgrades.
For example, modernizing a kitchen with updated countertops, cabinets, and energy-efficient appliances can increase a property’s appeal, making residents willing to pay a premium. Similarly, renovating bathrooms, adding in-unit laundry, or upgrading flooring with hardwood or luxury vinyl plank are strategic improvements that justify rent increases.
These upgrades enhance the property’s functionality and appeal, allowing you to position the rental in a higher price bracket.
Higher Property Value
Every dollar spent on renovations boosts rental income and increases the property’s overall market value. Renovations, especially in high-return areas like kitchens, bathrooms, and energy-efficient improvements, typically offer a return on investment (ROI) of 60-70% or more.
When it comes time to sell or refinance, these upgrades can significantly increase the appraised value, making your property a more attractive asset to potential buyers or lenders. Depending on the local real estate market and the scope of renovations, a well-renovated property can increase its value by up to 25%.
Attracting and Retaining High-Quality Residents
High-quality residents are drawn to properties that offer comfort, convenience, and modern amenities. Renovated properties, especially those with features like energy-efficient windows, smart home technology, or modern kitchens, attract residents who are willing to pay more and are more likely to stay longer.
This reduces resident turnover, saving you both time and money on marketing, vacancy periods, and resident screening. Long-term residents also tend to take better care of the property, further reducing wear-and-tear and maintenance costs over time.
Reduced Maintenance Costs
Older properties often come with the hidden cost of frequent repairs and maintenance.
Renovating outdated systems and appliances can significantly reduce ongoing maintenance expenses. Upgrading plumbing or electrical systems or installing a new HVAC system not only improves the resident experience but also minimizes the risk of costly repairs down the line.
Energy-efficient upgrades, such as new windows, insulation, or water-saving fixtures, reduce utility bills for residents, making the property more attractive, while also extending the life of the property’s infrastructure.
Increased Property Appeal in Competitive Markets
Residents have high expectations in today’s competitive rental market. Renovating your property ensures that it stays competitive, even in high-demand areas.
Properties that offer modern amenities, fresh design elements, and energy-efficient features consistently outperform those that haven’t been updated. Staying relevant with current trends—like installing smart home features or offering updated community spaces—helps position your property as a top choice in your rental market, reducing vacancy rates and ensuring consistent cash flow.
Budgeting for Renovations
Planning a renovation without a clear budget is a recipe for overspending and unfinished projects. To avoid these pitfalls, it’s essential to understand the factors influencing costs, know what to expect for common renovation expenses, and follow a structured approach to managing your budget effectively. When renovating a rental property, having a clear plan ensures you maximize your investment without unnecessary expenses.
Key Factors Influencing Renovation Costs
1. Scope of the Renovation
The extent of your renovation will have the most significant impact on your budget. Minor updates, such as repainting walls, replacing fixtures, or upgrading appliances, generally fall on the lower end of the cost spectrum. For example, a basic refresh like painting a room or replacing outdated lighting can cost as little as a few hundred dollars per room.
However, major overhauls—like gutting a kitchen, knocking down walls, or making structural changes—can easily cost tens of thousands of dollars.
For instance, a complete kitchen remodel with new countertops, cabinets, and appliances can start at $10,000 and rise sharply depending on the materials and finishes selected.
2. Home Size and Age
Larger homes naturally incur higher renovation costs due to the increased amount of materials and labor required. The cost per square footage can vary drastically depending on the renovation type and the quality of materials used.
For example, a 2,000-square-foot home will likely have higher overall costs than a smaller one. Additionally, older properties may require updates to comply with modern building codes. Outdated plumbing, electrical systems, or structural elements often need upgrading, and these hidden expenses can drive up the budget.
For homes built before 1978, it’s essential to factor in the presence of lead paint. Extensive renovations must be carried out by a lead-paint certified contractor, which can further increase the cost.
Renovating older homes can also lead to unexpected discoveries, such as asbestos removal or foundation repairs, adding thousands to the initial estimate.
3. Location
Location greatly impacts how much you’ll spend on a renovation. In cities with a high cost of living, like New York, Los Angeles, and San Francisco, renovations can cost anywhere from $50 to $150 per square foot. In more affordable places like Houston, Phoenix, and Fort Worth, costs are lower, around $25 to $80 per square foot.
According to Planner5d, if you’re renovating in an urban area, expect to pay between $50,000 and $75,000. Suburban areas typically fall between $40,000 and $60,000, while rural renovations are usually the least expensive, ranging from $35,000 to $55,000. Where you are can make a big difference in your overall budget.
Material costs can also fluctuate depending on regional availability, so be sure to account for geographic variations when planning your budget.
Average Renovation Costs for Rental Property
To give you a clearer picture of potential costs, here are the average price ranges for common renovation projects. These costs are reported directly from Home Guide’s report:
- Kitchen Remodel: Depending on the scope of the project, costs typically range from $10,000 to $50,000, with mid-range remodels landing between $29,000 and $64,000.
- Bathroom Remodel: The cost of a bathroom renovation can range from $5,000 to $25,000, with larger or more luxurious remodels costing even more.
- Living Room Renovation: Remodeling a living room usually costs between $4,000 and $10,000, covering updates like flooring, lighting, and painting.
- Roof Replacement: The cost of replacing a roof typically ranges from $5,601 to $11,729, depending on the size and materials used.
- Deck or Patio Addition: Adding a deck or patio generally costs between $2,200 and $10,000, depending on materials and size.
These figures can vary, but understanding these common costs will help you set a realistic budget.
Budgeting Steps
1. Define Your Goals
Before you start any renovation project, defining exactly what you want to achieve is critical. Are you aiming to increase rental income, enhance property value, or simply modernize an outdated space? This will help you prioritize necessary improvements over cosmetic changes. For example, updating a 1970s kitchen is likely more critical for increasing rental appeal than repainting a bedroom.
Focusing on functional upgrades ensures that every dollar spent translates to measurable returns.
2. Research Costs
Once you have your goals in place, it’s time to get clear on actual costs. Start by gathering estimates from local contractors. Aim for at least three quotes to get an accurate sense of the going rates for labor and materials in your area. Don’t rely solely on contractor quotes, though; use online resources to benchmark average costs for your region and type of renovation.
This due diligence will give you a comprehensive view of your renovation’s cost, helping you avoid sticker shock.
3. Set a Realistic Budget
Experts recommend allocating 10-15% of your property’s value toward renovations. This provides a solid framework for your budget while also aligning with your overall investment strategy. For example, if you own a rental property valued at $300,000, you should plan to spend between $30,000 and $45,000 on renovations.
Additionally, always include a contingency fund—about 20%—to cover unexpected issues like hidden water damage or outdated wiring, that can arise once the project is underway.
4. Itemize Your Budget
Breaking down your budget into specific categories helps avoid unforeseen expenses. Start by listing key categories: materials, labor, permits, and any potential living expenses if the property will be uninhabitable during the renovation.
For example, if you’re replacing a roof, factor in material costs, labor, permit fees, and a buffer for bad weather that could delay the project.
5. Consider Financing Options
If you don’t have the full renovation amount saved, consider financing options such as home equity lines of credit (HELOCs) or personal loans. These options provide the liquidity you need to complete your renovations without depleting your savings.
Be sure to shop around for competitive rates, and choose financing options with favorable terms to ensure you aren’t paying more than necessary in interest over time.
Tips for Staying Within Budget
- Be Realistic About Costs: Underestimating renovation expenses is a common mistake, so always overestimate when budgeting to cover unexpected costs. For example, if you plan to spend $20,000, consider budgeting for $24,000 to avoid surprises.
- Stick to Your Plan: Changing your renovation scope midway can dramatically increase costs. Finalize your plans before starting and avoid unnecessary changes, such as upgrading to high-end finishes during the project.
- DIY Where Possible: Take on smaller tasks like painting to save on labor, but leave complex work—like electrical or plumbing—to professionals. DIY can save money, but only when within your skill level to avoid costly errors.
Best Renovations for Rental Property for Maximum ROI
When renovating a rental property, focusing on projects that offer the best return on investment (ROI) ensures that your spending directly contributes to increased property value and higher rental income. According to the NAR 2022 Remodeling Impact Report, the following renovation ideas not only improve the appeal of your property but also provide substantial financial returns. According to the NAR report, these are the costs for various renovation activities:
1. Refinishing Hardwood Floors
Refinishing hardwood floors is among the highest-ROI renovations, with an incredible 147% cost recovery. This project enhances the aesthetics of any home, giving it a polished, well-maintained appearance, which attracts quality residents. The average cost for refinishing hardwood floors is around $3,400, while the estimated value recovered is $5,000.
Given hardwood’s longevity and timeless appeal, this renovation is a top choice for maximizing rental income and property value.
2. New Wood Flooring
Installing new wood flooring is another high-impact renovation, with an estimated 118% of costs recovered. New flooring significantly elevates the property’s perceived value, making it more appealing to prospective residents.
When considering new wood flooring for your home, it’s essential to account for both materials and labor. On average, you can expect to pay $7,000 to $25,000 for a 1,000-square-foot area, with the typical cost landing around $16,000.
This estimate includes both materials and labor, with most projects costing between $7 to $25 per square foot. The final price can vary depending on the type of wood you choose (solid or engineered), as well as the complexity of the installation.
3. Insulation Upgrade
An insulation upgrade boosts energy efficiency and offers a full 100% cost recovery, making it an excellent choice for both ROI and reducing long-term operating costs. Proper insulation ensures that heating and cooling systems operate more efficiently, saving residents money on utilities and potentially justifying higher rents. The average cost of upgrading insulation is about $2,500, with an equivalent recovery in value.
4. Kitchen Renovations
Kitchen upgrades are a staple for increasing property value and resident appeal. A complete kitchen renovation offers about 75% cost recovery, with average renovation costs around $80,000 and a recovered value of $60,000. While more expensive, kitchen remodels, including new cabinets, countertops, and appliances, drastically enhance a property’s functionality and aesthetics, making it easier to command higher rent.
5. Bathroom Renovations
Bathroom renovations significantly impact resident satisfaction and rental value. A typical bathroom renovation offers a 71% cost recovery, with an average project cost of $35,000 and a recovered value of $25,000. Upgrading bathroom fixtures, adding modern amenities, and improving layout and space can make a noticeable difference in attracting high-quality residents.
6. Attic Conversion to Living Area
Converting an attic into a living space can add significant square footage to the property, increasing its rental and resale value. This renovation has a 75% cost recovery, with a typical cost of $100,000 and a recovered value of $75,000. An attic conversion offers flexibility, whether as an additional bedroom, home office, or rental unit, giving you more options to attract residents.
Here’s a quick summary of these high-return renovations (if you want to explore these costs in more detail, you can have a look at the 2022 Remodeling Impact Report:
| Renovation | Average Cost | Value Recovered (ROI) |
| Refinishing Hardwood Floors | $3,400 | 147% ($5,000) |
| New Wood Flooring | $5,500 | 118% ($6,500) |
| Insulation Upgrade | $2,500 | 100% ($2,500) |
| Kitchen Renovations | $80,000 | 75% ($60,000) |
| Bathroom Renovations | $35,000 | 71% ($25,000) |
| Attic Conversion to Living Area | $100,000 | 75% ($75,000) |
Cheap Renovation Options on a Budget
Not all renovations require a significant investment. With some creativity and strategic choices, you can dramatically improve your rental property while keeping costs in check. Here are some of the most cost-effective rental renovation ideas that provide a big impact without breaking the bank:
1. Paint
Cost: $30-$60 per gallon
A fresh coat of paint can transform any space, giving it a clean, updated look. Painting walls, cabinets, or even furniture is a low-cost way to refresh a room’s aesthetic. Bold colors add personality, while lighter shades can create the illusion of larger, brighter spaces. For a typical room, painting costs roughly $200 to $300, making this one of the most affordable upgrades with noticeable results.
2. Update Light Fixtures
Cost: $50-$300 per fixture
Outdated light fixtures can make a room feel tired. Replacing them with modern, stylish fixtures instantly updates the look and feel of your space. Adding dimmer switches can also create customizable mood lighting, enhancing the resident’s experience. This affordable change significantly boosts a room’s appeal, particularly in common areas like kitchens and living rooms.
3. Change Cabinet Hardware
Cost: $2-$20 per piece
Swapping out cabinet hardware is a small but impactful update. New knobs, pulls, and handles can give kitchens and bathrooms a fresh, contemporary look without the need for full cabinet replacements. It’s a low-cost way to modernize spaces and elevate the overall design, making it a smart choice for budget-conscious renovators.
4. Refinish Existing Surfaces
Cost: $400-$900 for cabinets; $200 for bathtubs
Rather than replacing entire cabinets or bathtubs, refinishing is a cost-effective way to restore their appearance. This method can save you thousands while still giving your property a modernized look. Refinishing adds a sleek new finish for cabinets, while refinished bathtubs offer a like-new appearance at a fraction of the cost.
5. Add Open Shelving
Cost: $50-$200
Open shelving is an affordable alternative to installing new cabinets. Removing some upper cabinets and replacing them with open shelves can create a more open, airy feel in kitchens or living rooms. This trend is not only cost-efficient but also offers a modern look that appeals to many residents, allowing them to display decorative items.
6. Window Treatments
Cost: $30-$300
New window treatments, such as curtains or blinds, can dramatically change a room’s look. Affordable, pre-made options or DIY curtains from budget materials can add style and functionality without the cost of custom treatments. A simple update like this can refresh an entire space, especially when paired with other low-cost updates like new paint.
7. Create a Mudroom
Cost: $100-$300
A functional mudroom can be created in small spaces using repurposed furniture or affordable organizers. Adding hooks, a bench, and storage solutions provides residents with a practical entry space that keeps their home organized. It’s a small investment that offers big returns in convenience and resident satisfaction.
8. Replace Faucets and Fixtures
Cost: $50-$150 per faucet
Upgrading faucets in kitchens and bathrooms is a quick and easy way to modernize these spaces. New fixtures can update the look without requiring a full renovation, making it one of the simplest ways to enhance your rental property’s appeal on a budget.
9. DIY Artwork and Decor
Cost: Varies ($10-$100)
Personalizing spaces with DIY artwork or unique decor adds character to your property at a low cost. Thrift stores and budget-friendly craft supplies offer endless possibilities for creating one-of-a-kind pieces that give your rental a welcoming feel. This is an easy, low-cost way to make your property stand out from competitors.
In summary, here’s a quick table highlighting the cost and benefits of each of these:
| Renovation | Cost | Impact Summary |
| Paint | $30-$60 per gallon | Quick refresh for rooms, walls, or furniture |
| Update Light Fixtures | $50-$300 per fixture | Instant modern aesthetic with new designs |
| Change Cabinet Hardware | $2-$20 per piece | Fast, low-cost cabinet update |
| Install a New Backsplash | $200-$300 | Easy kitchen upgrade with visual appeal |
| Refinish Existing Surfaces | $400-$900 for cabinets, $200 for bathtubs | Restores appearance without replacement |
| Add Open Shelving | $50-$200 | Creates modern, airy feel in kitchens |
| Window Treatments | $30-$300 | Transforms a room with affordable options |
| Create a Mudroom | $100-$300 | Adds functional, organized space |
| Replace Faucets and Fixtures | $50-$150 per faucet | Modernizes bathrooms/kitchens affordably |
| DIY Artwork and Decor | Varies ($10-$100) | Adds personality and charm on a budget |
How to Renovate a Rental Property: Step-by-Step Guide
Renovating a rental property can seem overwhelming, but breaking it down into clear, manageable steps makes the process much easier to navigate.
Whether you’re doing a simple DIY upgrade or tackling a major structural overhaul, following a structured approach ensures that your project stays on time, within budget, and fully compliant with local regulations.
In this section, we’ll walk you through each step—from planning and securing permits to managing contractors and final inspections—so you can confidently execute your renovation and maximize your investment.
Step 1: Plan and Design Your Vision
Every successful renovation begins with a solid plan. Start by identifying your renovation goals. Are you focused on increasing property value, enhancing the space for resident satisfaction, or improving aesthetics? Once your goals are clear, it’s time to translate them into a blueprint.
Create a Blueprint: This design plan should outline all aspects of your renovation, including the layout, materials, and overall style. If the project is large or involves significant changes, consider hiring a professional designer or architect to ensure that your vision is practical and well-structured.
Step 2: Decide on DIY vs. Hiring Contractors
The decision to do the work yourself (DIY) or hire professionals depends on the complexity of the project, your skill set, and your time availability.
| Option | Pros | Cons |
| DIY |
|
|
| Hiring Contractors |
|
|
Step 3: Secure Permits and Understand Regulations
One of the most critical, yet often overlooked, aspects of renovating is securing the proper permits. Skipping this step can lead to fines, project delays, or even having to tear down completed work that doesn’t comply with local codes.
- What are Permits: Permits are legal approvals issued by your local government that allow you to proceed with renovations that may affect the property’s safety, structure, or functionality. Renovations like electrical work, plumbing, and structural changes often require permits to ensure they meet building codes and safety standards.
- When are Permits Needed: If your renovation involves changes to a building’s structure (e.g., adding or removing walls), plumbing, electrical systems, or even major exterior changes, you will likely need a permit. Projects like installing a new water heater, changing out a furnace, or building a deck typically require a permit as well. In contrast, smaller, cosmetic changes like painting or changing hardware usually do not.
- How to Get Permits:
-
- Contact Local Building Department: Start by reaching out to your city or county’s building department to determine what permits are required for your project. They will provide you with a list of the necessary forms and the process for submitting your application.
- Submit Your Plans: You must provide detailed plans, which may include blueprints or design layouts, for review. This helps ensure your renovation complies with local building codes.
- Pay Fees: Obtaining permits usually involves a fee, which varies depending on the project’s size and scope.
- Schedule Inspections: After your renovation begins, you will likely need to schedule one or more inspections to verify that the work complies with local regulations. Failing to pass an inspection could result in rework or additional fees.
- Contractor Responsibilities: Contractors are typically responsible for securing permits on your behalf. However, some may cut corners, either by neglecting to get the proper permits or by obtaining them after work has already started. To avoid legal and financial trouble, always verify that your contractor has applied for and received the necessary permits before starting the project. If you’re unsure, you can check with your local building department directly to ensure everything is in order.
Step 4: Set Timelines and Manage the Project
Once your plans are approved and your permits are secured, it’s time to organize your project timeline. Proper project management ensures your renovation stays on schedule and within budget.
- Create a Timeline: Break the renovation into phases—planning, demolition, construction, and final touches. Assign realistic timeframes to each phase, factoring in delays like bad weather or supply chain issues.
- Set Deadlines: Be sure to establish deadlines for each phase and communicate them clearly with your contractor. This will help prevent the project from dragging on longer than anticipated.
- Manage the Project: If you work with a contractor, check in regularly to monitor progress. Address any unexpected issues promptly and ensure the work aligns with your original vision.
Step 5: Execute the Renovation
With your permits secured and timeline in place, the next step is execution.
- DIY First: If you’re tackling any part of the project yourself, such as painting or installing fixtures, start with those. DIY work is usually best handled before contractors begin more complex tasks.
- Coordinate with Contractors: Ensure your contractors adhere to the timeline and deliver quality work. Check in regularly to ensure each phase progresses as planned and that any unforeseen problems are addressed immediately.
Step 6: Final Inspection and Finishing Touches
As your renovation nears completion, it’s time to focus on the finishing details and ensure everything is up to code.
- Schedule Final Inspections: If permits were required for the project, you’ll need to schedule a final inspection to verify that everything complies with local building codes. Ensure all work is completed satisfactorily before signing off with your contractor.
- Add Finishing Touches: Once the renovation is officially done, focus on the final details that complete the look—whether it’s hanging light fixtures, installing new hardware, or adding decor. These finishing touches will give your space a polished, finished feel.
Additional Considerations for Investors
Beyond the renovation process itself, investors need to consider the broader impact on residents, tax benefits, insurance coverage, and long-term maintenance.
Each of these factors plays a critical role in ensuring your renovation improves the property and protects and enhances your investment over time. Here are some tips for renovating an investment property that will be useful to you:
-
Resident Considerations – Minimizing Disruption: Renovations can be disruptive to residents, so it’s important to plan accordingly.
If residents occupy the property during renovations, aim to schedule work when they are least affected, or consider offering temporary housing alternatives. Clear communication is key—provide residents with detailed schedules and updates about the work being done to manage expectations and minimize inconvenience.
When renovations are necessary for safety or property improvements, ensure that residents understand the upgrade’s benefits and how they will enhance their living experience.
-
Tax Implications – Deductions and Depreciation: Investors can benefit from several tax deductions related to property renovations.
Certain renovation expenses, such as repairs and maintenance, may be deductible in the year they are incurred, while improvements may be depreciated over the property’s lifespan. This allows investors to recover costs over time.
Make sure to consult a tax professional to fully understand how your renovation costs can be leveraged for tax benefits. Rules can vary based on the type of work being done and local tax laws.
-
Insurance Coverage – Protecting Your Investment: Before beginning any renovation, review your property’s insurance policy.
Many policies require additional coverage during renovations, particularly if the project involves significant structural changes. Ensure that your policy covers potential damage, liability, and any unforeseen accidents that may occur during the renovation process.
It’s also wise to verify that your contractor carries adequate insurance, including workers’ compensation and liability coverage, to protect against accidents on-site.
-
Long-Term Maintenance – Planning for the Future: Renovations are not just about immediate upgrades—they also impact the property’s long-term maintenance needs.
When selecting materials and finishes, prioritize durability and ease of maintenance to reduce future repair costs. For example, high-quality flooring and energy-efficient appliances may cost more upfront but will save money in the long run through reduced wear and tear and lower utility costs.
Develop a maintenance schedule that includes routine inspections and repairs to keep the property in good condition and protect your investment for years to come.
In Conclusion
Renovating your rental property is one of the most effective ways to increase its value and attract high-quality residents. As we’ve covered, smart renovations—whether big or small—can directly impact your bottom line. Here’s a quick recap:
- Higher Rent and Property Value: Targeted updates, such as kitchen remodels or refinished flooring, can justify rent increases and significantly boost property value..
- Improved Resident Retention: Modern amenities attract quality residents and encourage them to stay longer, reducing vacancy rates.
- Cost-Effective Solutions: Even budget-friendly updates like fresh paint or new light fixtures can dramatically improve the property’s appeal without breaking the bank.
To get started:
- Prioritize What Matters: Focus on renovations that offer the best return on investment, such as kitchens, bathrooms, and energy efficiency improvements.
- Plan for Success: Create a budget, secure permits, and manage your timeline carefully to ensure a smooth renovation process.
- Stay Compliant: Ensure all work follows local regulations to avoid costly issues down the line.
Taking action now will ensure your property remains competitive and profitable in today’s rental market. Make a plan, and start turning your renovation into a long-term investment.
Managing renovations can be overwhelming, but a property management company can make the process seamless and increase your overall rental income.
Here are some more resources that will make your journey as a rental investor:
